I had seen videos of health care town hall meetings from across the country. I watched bewildered and amazed at the videos of red-faced men and women yelling and screaming like children having a tantrum. I’ve been appalled by the rudeness and crudeness of many in the crowds at these events.
But on my way to New River Community College’s Edwards Hall in Dublin on Tuesday to report on Rep. Rick Boucher’s town hall-style meeting on health care, I kept saying to myself, “Not here. We’re a more respectful people in the New River Valley. Surely we won’t see those outbursts that I’ve seen on TV.”
So much for my theory that we’re a more respectful people here in the NRV.
I guess, to be fair, that most of the outbursts weren’t as bad as many I had seen on TV, but there’s also no way that anyone present at the event could say the crowd assembled at Edwards Hall was particularly civil or respectful.
Here at the Voice, we believe in democracy. We believe everyone’s voice is important and should be heard—it’s why we named this publication New River Voice. We want to provide you with a forum to have your thoughts and opinions heard. (By the way, add your comments about this column below! We really do want to hear from you!) But heckling, booing, being disruptive, and hurling insults in a public forum isn’t expressing your views, it’s just being rude and disrespectful to those speaking and those trying to hear that speaker.
I didn’t agree with everything that Boucher said at the meeting. I admit I chuckled to myself a couple times at his straddling the fence and playing to both sides of the health care debate in typical politician style. But I never had such anger that I wanted to yell at the guy, or at any of the three panelists, or at fellow citizens asking a question or making a statement. I never was moved to wave a “Don’t Tread on Me” flag or to sing “God Bless America.”
And more than the health care debate that is raging in this country, I guess that’s my biggest concern—the rage.
Some of these people were angry when they drove to Edwards Hall, angry during all three hours of the meeting, and angry when they left. The vast majority of those illustrating, in my opinion, an unhealthy dose of hostility were against health care reform.
And my guess is that many of thos folks have their hostility fueled by the likes of media personalities such as Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh, Bill O’Reilly and others. Fans of these unfortunately popular pundits don’t want to be controlled by the government, yet they allow themselves and their emotions to be controlled by the likes of guys who don’t even believe half of what comes out of their own mouths.
Do you think Glenn Beck really believes all the crap he’s been espousing about health care lately? If so, you need to watch this video clip that illustrates the man’s utter hypocrisy. These guys get paid millions of dollars to enrage you. Fortunately for them, they are good at their jobs. People are indeed steaming mad. And it’s tearing apart our country.
Many of these angry folks turned their ire toward Boucher when he said that a lot of people didn’t comprehend many of the details of the legislation being considered in Congress. The angry mob took this as a slap in the face—that Boucher was saying they were too stupid to understand something.
I hate to defend Boucher because I disagree with him on a lot of issues, but there are five major bills being debated in Congress right now and I sure can’t comprehend the details of them all. I was at the meeting Tuesday, in part, to try to comprehend the details of health care legislation. But some folks are not concerned with reason, rationale, or facts.
I just read an interesting piece from Rem Rieder, editor and publisher of American Journalism Review. In it, Rieder writes, “America has become a country filled with people who stubbornly continue to believe what they want to believe, regardless of the facts.”
He gives the example of “those who embrace the notion that the health care legislation working its way through Congress would establish ‘death panels’ that would ‘pull the plug on grandma,’ even though it clearly wouldn’t.”
Rieder goes on to say that “it’s the job of journalists to sort out such contretemps, to determine where the truth lies. But what do you do when a significant portion of the electorate ignores the findings?”
And what do you do when people view guys such as Beck, Limbaugh, and O’Reilly as journalists and believe the lies and vitriol that come out of their mouths every day?
Most of us don’t comprehend the details of proposed health care legislation because we are getting our information—and in some cases misinformation—from very one-sided sources. I implore my fellow citizens of the New River Valley to ease up on the hostility, take a break from the pundits paid to make you angry, and really study the health care issue using independent sources.
Wanting health care for our neighbors should be a goal for all of us. Are we really so hostile about this issue that our response to Boucher’s statement about wanting affordable health care for everyone is to boo?
Sadly, yes, apparently we really are that angry.
Tim W. Jackson is Editor of the New River Voice and wants to hear your opinion. Give us your thoughts (in a civil manner, of course!) below.

3 responses so far ↓
1 blake // Aug 19, 2009 at 11:28 am
That clip of Beck’s hypocrisy is really sad. What day did the news turn into entertainment? The day CNN first aired? Has it always been?
2 The Man Who Snarls // Aug 19, 2009 at 11:44 am
This is a compelling commentary on how we as a society receive, perceive, and respond to news. The perplexity you express over the crowd’s need for outbursts is exactly why I refuse to involve myself in politics or controversy. I can tolerate a lot of things, but I can’t tolerate an utter refusal to give opposing viewpoints the time of day.
“Ego interference.” They has it.
Bloody good piece, Dr. Jackson.
3 Thomas Lansing // Aug 19, 2009 at 11:10 pm
Look at what our current government has done for us. With the second stimulus, and the new budget, they have put forth two of the spend-heaviest bills in the history of any nation. Add to that the major bank bailout which was supposed to free the credit market. Each of these bills has either done nothing, or accomplished the complete opposite of their target goals – and guess who will be picking up the check!!!! With the track record of the democratic party in this term so far, the rage felt by the crowds is understandable now that the politicians want to mess with health care.
The bill they are trying to put forth right now is extremely large and confusing. That therefore makes it less open to the common person. This is something that will impact EVERY American both in our standard of care AND our wallets. The crowds understand this, and thus are afraid. The question is, do our politicians understand, they are voted into office to look after our best interests – again by their track record so far this term it doesn’t look that way!
Leave a Comment